01—Abstract
Summary
Summary of the 10-K filed February 24, 2017. Cited figures are marked; the original filing is the authoritative source.
Moody's Corporation (MCO) reported 2016 results dominated by an $863.8 milliona Settlement Charge recorded in Q4 2016 related to a January 13, 2017 agreement with the U.S. Department of Justice and 21 states plus D.C. over credit ratings MIS assigned to structured finance instruments during the financial crisis.
Excluding that charge and a $12.0 millionb restructuring charge, the underlying business performed well: revenue grew 3% to $3,604.2 million, with MA (Moody's Analytics) revenue up 7% (10% in constant currency) and MIS revenue up 2%. Adjusted Operating Income rose 3% to $1,641.2 million, with Adjusted Operating Margin flat at 45.5%. Reported GAAP operating income fell 57% to $638.7 million, GAAP diluted EPS dropped to $1.36 from $4.63, and Adjusted Diluted EPS was $4.81, up 5%.
Balance sheet and cash flow are the key watch items. Shareholders' deficit widened to $(1,027.3) million, driven by share repurchases of $738.8 millionc and dividends. Operating cash flow was $1,226.1 million and Free Cash Flow was $1,110.9 million, which supported continued capital returns.
Because most of the settlement was payable in Q1 2017, Moody's began issuing commercial paper ($566.0 milliond outstanding as of February 22, 2017) and planned to prepay $300 million of 6.06% Series 2007-1 Notes in March 2017. Management expected full-year 2017 share repurchases of about $500 million and a quarterly dividend of $0.38 per share. The filing also highlights ongoing regulatory and litigation exposure for MIS, including EU and U.S. rules, and risks to the structured finance and volume-driven ratings business.
Cybersecurity, third-party technology dependence, and goodwill impairment risk in the MAKS reporting unit (after a January 2017 management change) are also flagged. Overall, the headline GAAP results are distorted by a one-time charge, while the recurring earnings base and cash generation remain intact.
02—Key points
Key Highlights
- Q4 2016 included an $863.8 million Settlement Charge ($700.7 million after tax, or $3.59 per diluted share) tied to the DOJ and state AG settlement over financial-crisis-era structured finance ratings.
- Revenue rose 3% to $3,604.2 million; MA revenue grew 7% (10% constant currency) and MIS revenue grew 2%.
- GAAP operating margin fell to 17.7% from 42.3%, while Adjusted Operating Margin held flat at 45.5% and Adjusted Operating Income rose 3% to $1,641.2 million.
- GAAP diluted EPS was $1.36 versus $4.63 in 2015; Adjusted Diluted EPS was $4.81, up 5%.
- Operating cash flow was $1,226.1 million and Free Cash Flow was $1,110.9 million, both up year over year.
- The shareholders' deficit widened to $(1,027.3) million, and $738.8 million was spent on share repurchases in 2016 with roughly $727 million of authorization remaining.
- Near-term liquidity: the company began CP borrowings in Q1 2017 to fund the settlement payment and planned a ~$316 million prepayment of the 2007-1 Notes in March 2017.
03—One dollar
04—Financials
Financial Highlights
Figures from 10-KFY2016filed February 24, 2017Financial Statements
FY2016 against FY2015
| Line item | FY2016FY2015 | Change |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $3.60B$3.48B | +3.4% |
| R&D Expenses | $40.10M$29.10M | +37.8% |
| SG&A Expenses | $931.20M$921.30M | +1.1% |
| Operating Expenses | $2.95B$2.01B | +46.8% |
| Operating Income | $650.90M$1.47B | −55.8% |
| Net Income | $266.60M$941.30M | −71.7% |
| EPS (Basic) | $1.38$4.70 | −70.6% |
| EPS (Diluted) | $1.36$4.63 | −70.6% |
| Shares Outstanding (Basic) | 192.70M200.10M | −3.7% |
| Shares Outstanding (Diluted) | 195.40M203.40M | −3.9% |
05—Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
How large was the one-time charge, and how does it affect reported results?
The Settlement Charge was $863.8 million pre-tax ($700.7 million after tax, or $3.59 per diluted share). It drove 2016 GAAP operating income down 57% to $638.7 million and GAAP diluted EPS to $1.36. Excluding the charge and restructuring, Adjusted Operating Income rose 3% and Adjusted Diluted EPS was $4.81.
What does the settlement resolve, and is there an admission of liability?
The January 13, 2017 agreement with the U.S. DOJ, the U.S. Attorney's Office for New Jersey, and 21 states plus D.C. resolves civil claims over credit ratings MIS assigned to certain structured finance instruments in the financial crisis era. Moody's pays $437.5 million to the U.S. and $426.3 million in aggregate to the states, and agrees to compliance measures over five years. The agreement contains no findings of violations of law and no admission of liability.
How is the company funding the near-term cash outflow and capital returns?
Most of the settlement is payable in Q1 2017, so Moody's began issuing commercial paper under its $1 billion CP program. $566.0 million was outstanding as of February 22, 2017, at a weighted average rate of 1.18%. The company also plans to prepay $300 million of 6.06% Series 2007-1 Notes (about $316 million including interest and penalties) on March 20, 2017. Management expects about $500 million of 2017 share repurchases, subject to cash and market conditions.
What are the main risks to the ratings business going forward?
The filing cites exposure to debt issuance volumes and interest rates, rising regulatory burdens in the U.S. and EU (including ESMA oversight and mandatory rotation rules), ongoing litigation from market participants tied to MIS-rated securities, pricing pressure from competitors, and a European ratings platform that makes some issuer-paid rating information free. It also flags the risk of goodwill impairment in the MAKS reporting unit after a January 2017 management change, along with cybersecurity and third-party technology dependence.
06—Continue