10-QPeriod: Q3 FY2006

PROGRESSIVE CORP/OH/ Quarterly Report for Q3 Ended Sep 30, 2006

Filed November 2, 2006For Securities:PGR

Summary

The Progressive Corporation (PGR) reported strong financial results for the third quarter and nine months ended September 30, 2006. Net income increased significantly year-over-year, driven by lower catastrophe losses compared to the active hurricane season in 2005 and continued solid underwriting profitability. The company experienced slower written premium growth, attributed to "soft" market conditions and increased competition, leading to a decline in new business applications. However, policies in force saw positive growth, indicating a focus on customer retention. Investment income also showed a substantial increase, reflecting higher yields and a larger investment portfolio. The company maintained a strong capital position and robust cash flow from operations, enabling continued share repurchases and the planned transition to an annual variable dividend policy in 2007. Management is focused on improving customer retention by moderating pricing where appropriate while maintaining profitability targets.

Key Highlights

  • 1Net income for the third quarter increased 34% to $409.6 million ($0.53 per share), and for the nine months increased 12% to $1,246.6 million ($1.58 per share), benefiting from lower catastrophe losses compared to Q3 2005.
  • 2Total revenues grew 3% for the quarter to $3,723.8 million and 4% for the nine months to $11,092.6 million.
  • 3The combined ratio improved to 87.3% for the third quarter from 90.4% in the prior year's quarter, and for the nine months improved to 86.4% from 87.2%.
  • 4Net premiums earned increased 2% for the quarter to $3,544.3 million and 3% for the nine months to $10,609.2 million, with Personal Lines showing 1% growth and Commercial Auto showing 11% growth for the quarter.
  • 5Investment income significantly increased by 23% for the quarter and 25% for the nine months, contributing to overall profitability.
  • 6The company repurchased approximately 14.3 million shares in the third quarter for $346.8 million as part of its share repurchase program.
  • 7Progressive announced plans to transition to an annual variable dividend policy in 2007, moving away from its current quarterly dividend.

Frequently Asked Questions

The significant increase in net income was primarily driven by a substantial reduction in catastrophe losses in Q3 2006 compared to the active hurricane season in Q3 2005. The prior year period was heavily impacted by events like Hurricane Katrina.

Slower written premium growth is attributed to current 'soft' market conditions in the insurance industry, characterized by stable or decreasing rates and reduced customer shopping. This has led to a decrease in new business applications. Progressive's strategy is to focus on customer retention by lowering rates where appropriate, aiming to grow as fast as possible while maintaining a combined ratio of 96 or better.

Progressive adopted SFAS 123(R) on January 1, 2006. This standard requires the recognition of compensation expense for share-based awards. While the company began recording expense for restricted stock awards, the adoption, particularly using the modified prospective method, had a minimal effect on its reported financial results for the nine months ended September 30, 2006, as prior periods were not restated and the expense recognition for outstanding stock options will cease in 2007.

Progressive plans to replace its current quarterly dividend policy in 2007 with an annual variable dividend. This new policy will use a target percentage of after-tax underwriting income, multiplied by a 'Gainshare factor' that considers premium growth and profitability, potentially ranging from zero to two. The first payout under this new policy is expected in early 2008.