01—Abstract
Summary
Summary of the 10-K/A filed March 30, 2009. Cited figures are marked; the original filing is the authoritative source.
This Part III amendment of Sun Communities, Inc.'s 2008 Form 10-K covers corporate governance, executive and director compensation, security ownership, related-party transactions, and auditor fees.
The Board has eight directors, six of whom are identified as independent under NYSE rules, and met seven times in 2008. Chairman and CEO Gary A. Shiffman, who also serves as President, is the largest holder, with 2,006,296 shares (10.8%a of outstanding shares as of March 26, 2009, when 18,509,130 shares were outstanding).
The directors and executive officers as a group hold 16.8%. Shiffman's total 2008 compensation was $1,493,639b. Named executive officers earned aggregate bonuses of $534,343 for 2008, which the Compensation Committee tied to Adjusted FFO growth of 2.9 percent against a target of three to five percent.
The filing also states that Brian W. Fannon retired effective July 31, 2008, with a severance of $332,288c payable through April 2009. The filing discloses several related-party arrangements.
The Company has a capital investment in Origen Financial, Inc., on whose board Shiffman sits, and it purchased approximately $12.4 milliond of loans from Origen during 2008. Shiffman's personal promissory notes to the Company had approximately $5.4 million outstanding as of March 15, 2009, down from a largest aggregate balance of about $8.7 million since January 1, 2008. The Company paid approximately $1.0 million in 2008 legal fees to Jaffe, Raitt, Heuer & Weiss, whose chairman, director Arthur A.
Weiss, is a shareholder. The Company also leases its principal executive offices from American Center LLC, in which Shiffman and Weiss hold indirect interests, under a lease extended to August 31, 2015. Grant Thornton LLP served as independent auditor.
Audit fees were $419,120 for 2008 and audit-related fees were $41,000, with no tax or other fees. The Audit Committee pre-approved all services, and the filing states that Grant Thornton's non-audit fees are compatible with auditor independence. The Compensation Committee's report notes that the Compensation Discussion and Analysis is included in this amended report.
02—Key points
Key Highlights
- Board of eight directors, six identified as independent under NYSE rules; the Board met seven times in 2008, and the Audit Committee met six times.
- Chairman, CEO and President Gary A. Shiffman beneficially owns 2,006,296 shares, or 10.8% of outstanding shares; directors and executive officers as a group hold 16.8%.
- Five-percent holders named are The Vanguard Group (8.04%), Barclays Global Investors (7.4%) and Wells Fargo & Company (5.4%), based on 2008 Schedule 13G filings.
- Named executive officers earned aggregate 2008 bonuses of $534,343, based on Adjusted FFO growth of 2.9 percent against a three to five percent objective.
- Related-party exposure includes Origen Financial transactions (loan purchases of about $12.4 million in 2008), Shiffman's promissory notes with about $5.4 million outstanding as of March 15, 2009, and about $1.0 million in 2008 legal fees paid to a firm where director Arthur A. Weiss is a shareholder.
- Brian W. Fannon retired effective July 31, 2008, receiving severance of $332,288 payable ratably through April 2009, and his stock awards fully vested.
- Grant Thornton LLP audit fees were $419,120 for 2008 and audit-related fees were $41,000, with no tax or other fees.
03—One dollar
04—Financials
Financial Highlights
Figures from 10-K/AFY2009filed March 30, 2009Financial Statements
| Revenue | $259.02M |
| Operating Expenses | $263.59M |
| Operating Income | $144.54M |
| Interest Expense | $62.78M |
| Net Income | -$6.30M |
| EPS (Basic) | $-0.34 |
| Shares Outstanding (Basic) | 18.48M |
| Shares Outstanding (Diluted) | 18.48M |
05—Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
How much control does the CEO have over the Company?
Gary A. Shiffman beneficially owns 2,006,296 shares, or 10.8% of outstanding shares as of March 26, 2009. That figure includes Common OP Units, options exercisable within 60 days, and shares held by limited liability companies he manages.
How was executive bonus pay determined for 2008?
The Compensation Committee reviewed individual performance and Company objectives, including Adjusted FFO growth of 2.9 percent against a target of three to five percent, budgeted revenue-producing site and net operating income targets, and overall performance. Bonuses for named executive officers totaled $534,343, with Shiffman receiving $239,260.
Are there conflicts of interest involving related parties?
Yes. Shiffman sits on the board of Origen Financial, in which the Company holds an investment, and the Company bought loans from Origen. Shiffman's personal promissory notes to the Company had about $5.4 million outstanding as of March 15, 2009. The Company's executive offices are leased from an entity in which Shiffman and Weiss hold interests. The filing states that all related-party transactions were approved by the Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee or the full Board.
What did the Company pay its auditor?
Grant Thornton LLP received $419,120 in audit fees and $41,000 in audit-related fees for 2008. No tax or other fees were paid, and the Audit Committee pre-approved all services.
06—Continue