01—Abstract
Summary
Summary of the 10-K/A filed May 17, 2005. Cited figures are marked; the original filing is the authoritative source.
This Form 10-K/A amends W.
P. Carey & Co. LLC's annual report for fiscal 2004 to restate 2004 financial statements. The restatement corrects a clerical error that overstated the provision for income taxes by $1,990 thousanda, so restated 2004 income from continuing operations is $71,038 thousand (previously reported $69,048 thousand) and net income is $65,841 thousand (previously $63,851 thousand).
Restated basic earnings per share are $1.76b (previously $1.71) and diluted are $1.69 (previously $1.64). Management concluded that a material weakness in controls over the calculation of deferred taxes existed at December 31, 2004, so disclosure controls and internal control over financial reporting were deemed not effective. The company is a real estate investment, management and advisory firm.
At December 31, 2004 it owned 168 U.S. properties and 15 European properties totaling more than 19.4 million square feet, net leased to more than 107 tenants, and it managed over 765 net leased properties for the CPA REITs. Revenues for 2004 were $227,774 thousandc, up from $159,238 thousand in 2003, with management services revenue of $148,457 thousand including $42,095 thousand of incentive and subordinated disposition fees tied to the 2004 merger of Carey Institutional Properties into CPA:15. Total assets were $1,013,539 thousand and cash dividends paid were $65,073 thousand.
The filing also highlights risks that investors should weigh: an ongoing SEC investigation into payments to broker-dealers and a possible enforcement action, reliance on a single selling dealer for CPA REIT capital raising, and concentration of revenue in advisory fees. CPA:16 - Global suspended and later withdrew its best efforts offering, which the filing says has deferred roughly $7,535 thousandd of transaction fees and $819 thousand of performance fees until a preferred return criterion is met.
02—Key points
Key Highlights
- Restatement: 2004 provision for income taxes reduced by $1,990 thousand due to a clerical error; restated net income is $65,841 thousand versus $63,851 thousand previously reported.
- Restated diluted earnings per share of $1.69 for 2004, versus $1.64 as previously reported.
- Material weakness in internal control over the calculation and review of deferred taxes; disclosure controls and internal control over financial reporting were concluded not effective as of December 31, 2004.
- Total revenues of $227,774 thousand in 2004, up from $159,238 thousand in 2003, driven by $42,095 thousand of incentive and subordinated disposition fees from the CIP and CPA:15 merger.
- Portfolio of 168 U.S. and 15 European properties totaling more than 19.4 million square feet, with over 765 properties managed for the CPA REITs.
- Ongoing SEC investigation into broker-dealer payments and REIT distribution arrangements; the filing states an enforcement action could materially affect the company.
- Credit facility of $225,000 thousand with $102,000 thousand outstanding at December 31, 2004; the filing states the company was in compliance with covenants.
03—Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was this 10-K/A filed and what changed?
The filing restates the 2004 financial statements to correct a clerical error in the deferred tax calculation for a subsidiary developing a single property. The error overstated the provision for income taxes by $1,990 thousand. Restated 2004 net income is $65,841 thousand, compared with $63,851 thousand previously reported. The restatement also increased members' equity by $1,990 thousand and reduced deferred income taxes payable by the same amount. Cash flows were not affected.
What did the restatement mean for the company's internal controls?
Management concluded that its controls over the calculation and review of the provision for income taxes were not effective as of December 31, 2004, constituting a material weakness. Management stated that it began remediation in May 2005 with an additional level of review and expected to complete further procedures during the second quarter of 2005. Accordingly, the CEO and CFO concluded that disclosure controls were not effective.
What drove the increase in 2004 revenue and income?
The filing attributes the increase to fees earned on the merger of Carey Institutional Properties into CPA:15, including incentive fees of $23,681 thousand and disposition fees of $22,679 thousand, plus $11,493 thousand of transaction fees. It also cites higher asset-based management fees from a 41% increase in the asset base of the CPA REITs. The filing notes that no liquidity events are currently planned, so such fee streams may not recur predictably.
What is the SEC investigation about and what could it mean for investors?
The SEC Enforcement Staff is investigating compliance with Securities Act registration requirements for CPA:15 offerings in 2002 and 2003, and broker-dealer compensation arrangements in connection with CPA:15 and other managed REITs. The company and its broker-dealer subsidiary Carey Financial are cooperating, and no regulatory action has been initiated. The filing states that if an action is brought it could have a material adverse effect on the company, and that the timing and relief sought cannot be predicted.
How concentrated is the business with respect to tenants and dealers?
The five largest tenants and guarantors, occupying 15 properties, represented approximately 25% of total net leasing revenues in 2004. The company also states it is overly reliant on American Express Financial Advisors, Inc. to market CPA REIT offerings. Winn-Dixie, a lessee at the Bay Minette, Alabama property, has indicated it intends to terminate its lease after filing Chapter 11 bankruptcy, with annual rent of $128 thousand from that property.
04—Continue