01—Abstract
Summary
Summary of the 10-K filed March 12, 2004. Cited figures are marked; the original filing is the authoritative source.
Moody's Corporation's fiscal 2003 10-K shows a company in strong growth mode.
Revenue rose 21.8% to $1,246.6 milliona, operating income grew 23.2% to $663.1 million, and net income increased 26.0% to $363.9 million, with diluted EPS of $2.39 versus $1.83 in 2002. Growth was driven by structured finance, corporate finance, and research at Moody's Investors Service (about 91% of revenue), with the KMV credit-risk business (acquired April 2002) growing more slowly and at lower margins. Operating cash flow reached $468.4 million, and the company repurchased $171.7 million of stock.
Management guides to mid-to-high single-digit revenue growth in 2004, with operating margin compression of roughly 200 basis points from investment spending and stock-based compensation expense. The balance sheet remains unusual. Shareholders' equity is negative at $(32.1) million, a deficit that reflects cumulative buybacks and the spin-off structure, and $300 millionb of 7.61% notes are due October 2005.
The more significant investor risk is contingent liabilities inherited from the 2000 separation from Old D&B. Management estimates potential legacy tax cash outlays of as much as $331 millionc, against reserves of about $126 million. Moody's also faces an unaccrued AFPER lawsuit in France seeking roughly $3.5 billion, with a judgment scheduled for April 6, 2004, and an IRI antitrust action in which Moody's is exposed to a 25% share of any judgment above a threshold.
For investors, the 2003 results show strong operating leverage and cash generation, supported by favorable interest rate conditions that boosted refinancing and securitization activity. The company's 2004 outlook signals a slowdown in U.S. residential mortgage ratings and public finance, as well as rising interest rates. Investors should weigh the strong earnings trajectory against litigation and tax exposures that could be material and are not fully reserved.
02—Key points
Key Highlights
- Revenue grew 21.8% to $1,246.6 million, and diluted EPS rose 30.6% to $2.39 from $1.83, with operating margin improving to 53.2%.
- Moody's Investors Service delivered $1,134.7 million in revenue (up 20.5%), led by structured finance (+19.9%), corporate finance (+22.4%), and research (+35.6%).
- Moody's KMV contributed $111.9 million in revenue (up 37.3% reported; 15.8% pro forma) and a $6.0 million operating profit, reflecting lower margins than the ratings business.
- Operating cash flow was $468.4 million, and the company returned capital through $171.7 million in share repurchases and $26.8 million in dividends.
- Shareholders' equity remains negative at $(32.1) million, and $300 million of 7.61% notes mature in October 2005.
- Legacy tax exposures could total up to $331 million in cash outlays, against reserves of about $126 million; a $16.2 million reserve increase in Q4 2003 hit the tax provision.
- The AFPER lawsuit in France seeks approximately $3.5 billion; no amount is accrued, and a judgment was scheduled for April 6, 2004. The IRI antitrust case also carries unquantified exposure.
03—Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
What drove Moody's strong 2003 revenue growth?
Growth came mainly from high debt issuance volumes, favorable interest rates, and strong structured finance activity, especially U.S. residential mortgage-backed securities and European CDOs. Research and corporate finance also grew well, and price increases contributed. About 200 basis points of reported growth came from currency translation.
Why is shareholders' equity negative, and is that a concern?
The deficit comes from a combination of the 2000 spin-off structure, cumulative share repurchases totaling $881 million since the spin-off, and dividends. Because Moody's generates strong recurring cash flow, the negative equity has not impaired its ability to fund operations, but it limits the book-value cushion investors can rely on.
What is the biggest risk to investors from legal and tax matters?
The legacy tax matters, inherited from Old D&B, could require up to about $331 million in cash, far above the roughly $126 million reserved. Moody's believes the IRS is unlikely to prevail on both of its conflicting positions. The AFPER lawsuit (about $3.5 billion sought) is considered without merit by management, but an adverse outcome would be material.
What does management expect for 2004?
Management expects mid-to-high single-digit revenue growth, with a public finance revenue decline of about 20% and a U.S. residential mortgage decline as refinancing slows. Operating margin is expected to fall about 200 basis points from investment spending and higher stock-based compensation. Diluted EPS is expected to grow in the mid-to-high single-digit range.
How much does the KMV acquisition contribute, and what is its risk profile?
Moody's KMV, acquired in April 2002 for $212.6 million, generated $111.9 million in 2003 revenue and $6.0 million in operating income. Its margins are lower than the core ratings business, and management expects it to grow faster in 2004 at high-teens revenue growth, which will weigh on consolidated margins.
04—Continue